As a parent, I sometimes return home to find the house in disarray. Things are out of place, some rooms are a mess and the guilty parties are nowhere to be found. Clearly, something has been happening. Eventually I round up the two suspects and ask them the fundamental question.
“How did things get the way they are?”
Usually they exchange glances that contain a wealth of information about possible answers to that question. They seem to calculate the pluses and minuses of each possible answer. Denial (a favorite response) ignores the obvious evidence and lack of alternative causes. Blame means admitting involvement though, of course, the intent is to deflect responsibility to the other party. Excuses attempt to substitute an inferior explanation for the correct one. Silence is stonewalling and an implicit appeal to mercy. Occasionally (just enough to restore my faith and hope), there is an admission of responsibility. Why is that so hard, I am left to wonder?
It is not so different in business.
We enjoy results that might be good (but not good enough) or we suffer through obviously unacceptable outcomes. Then the same question comes to us -“How did things get the way they are?” Confronting that question correctly often determines what comes next. If, on one hand, we attempt all of the responsibility evasions mastered by children in homes around the world, we risk worsening results. On the other hand, when we responsibly answer the question, we lay the foundation for a second important question.
Before I get to the second question, it is useful to remember three fundamental abilities required for management as described by Jerry Weinberg in his Quality Software Management, Volume 1. These abilities allow a manager to meaningfully decipher and respond to difficult situations including “messes” encountered at work.
Read the rest of this entry